Remove Redstone Comparator as a goal

Open

Loven20 messagesstarted Sep 14, 2026, 8:40 PM

objectives

LovenOPlast week(edited)

Obtain Redstone Comparator seems a bit redundant as a sole goal since the new addition of "Power of Books", which is essentially redstone comparator + 6 planks and 3 slabs.

297

sugaarushlast week

yea plus we have redstoen repeater already (plus a bunch of quartz goals)

577last week

theres like 2 other quartz goals

StarFaintlast week

It's ok to have some goals that share an item

StarFaintlast week

No need to remove anything that shares a raw material with another

sugaarushlast week

yea but quartz is already just the same as enter nether

577last week

No it isn't

StarFaintlast week

You'd remove a quarter of the goals with that logic.

Lexingtoniuslast week

i see this take all the time but it just isnt true, like you need either prep beforehand, a large time investment or rarer resources for all (3?) quartz goals beyond just finding the enter

2 things sharing a step does not make them the same, or essentially the same aga

SparkFire_last week

we've already lost observer why another :(

beniibobslast week

Ok but the “step” in power of books and obtain comparator is like 90% of the goal

crturtlelast week

quartz itself is but all the goals which need it require other resources too (stonecutter/redstone/glass) so i dont think theres really an issue with quartz in general, but for comparator and power of books specifically i do agree that theyre too similar