Standardise witch drops

Open

Streakify29 messagesstarted Aug 28, 2026, 4:20 PM

gameplay

StreakifyOP4 weeks ago

Had a game where the witch dropped a healing pot for me whilst my opponent only got redstone, helped me win 2 goals since wash something off cauldron and water bottle were both on the board

1821

StreakifyOP4 weeks ago

thought this was alr implemented lowk

DriftSythe4 weeks ago

I thought the witch can only drop healing while it’s drinking it

Ｂｒｅａｄ4 weeks ago

potions can drop when the witch is killed while drinking it

Ｂｒｅａｄ4 weeks ago

we need to test if its standardize when both player's witch is drinking

Ｂｒｅａｄ4 weeks ago

unless thats what streakify is implying

DriftSythe4 weeks ago

yea if it’s drinking for both players its drop should be standardized if it’s not

sam4 weeks ago

Confirming this is not standardized

sam4 weeks ago

If two players kill a witch while it’s drinking healing pot, they can get different outcomes

sam4 weeks ago(edited)

This is a vanilla thing - draftout doesn’t to do anything to standardize mob drops at the moment because vanilla does already

Anyway it should be standardized obviously (for the case where both players have the same eligible drops)

beniibobs4 weeks ago

A lot of mobs have the 8.5% to drop their held item - is it also not standardised for those either? (skeleton bow etc.)

Threadfinn4 weeks ago

Should it be standardized across potion types or each potion separately? Like if one kills with healing pot while the other tries for fire res should they always have both/neither drop or should different held items count differently?

awesomeSallad4 weeks ago

Definitely each potion separately because of the hypothetical situation where a player wants to try for healing and fire res and the order doesn’t matter. Separately standardizes brain rng, if that makes sense

maskers4 weeks ago

makes me wonder, what happens if
for player 1: a skeleton dies naturally in a cave -> you kill a skeleton
for player 2: you kill a skeleton
idk if this can realistically happen

sam4 weeks ago

good point - skeleton bow drops aren't standardized either

sam4 weeks ago

i would say each potion separately

sam4 weeks ago

rn ya the players get different drops

maskers4 weeks ago(edited)

are the drops just fully independent if this happens or is player 2 one drop behind

maskers4 weeks ago

or smth else idk

beniibobs4 weeks ago

I would assume they’re just independent rolls

maskers4 weeks ago

if this can realistically happen

surely its realistic to blow up a skeleton with a creeper without hitting it before

maskers4 weeks ago

so assuming ^ its theoretically possible to get a bow from a skeleton with 2 skeletons while ur opponent needs to kill 50
if you blow up the first skeleton

maskers4 weeks ago(edited)

oh well if bows were standardised ig, maybe string from spiders is a better example

sam4 weeks ago

for bones, player 2 is one drop behind

sam4 weeks ago(edited)

for bow, the roll is fully independent

Threadfinn4 weeks ago

What about for blaze rods, or anything else that is dependent on player kill?

Threadfinn4 weeks ago

If one dies of natural causes does it still count towards the counter for player kills?

sam4 weeks ago

So for blaze it doesn’t advance it, but for spider it does (so your spider eye drop can get eaten by an ineligible death)

beniibobslast week

Implemented now