remove pale garden seed and pale garden related goals

Open

mr. pineapple22 messagesstarted Jul 26, 2026, 1:03 AM

gameplay

mr. pineappleOP2 months ago

this seed is awful i get it in like half my games and its always a dark oak forest, a birch forest, and a pale garden all next to each other. since there are only 2 pale garden related goals and most of the times those goals aren't even chosen it just doesn't make any sense

617

masomarek092 months ago

I dont agree as a structureless seed it makes you think different about what are you gonna do. Maybe you see some small cave from bird view for quick bucket and nether enter. Or there can be an ocean nearby and hope for a ship.

blanket addict2 months ago

I don't see any reason to remove the pale garden goals they're like monument goals

mr. pineappleOP2 months ago

Since pale gardens are rarer than monuments

Vapcr2 months ago

pale garden isn't necessarily a seed type, it's encompassed in the "misc" seedtype. If you get a pale garden, chances are there's a mansion in the nearby dark forest which has hella stuff

Threadfinn2 months ago

The difference is monuments aren't currently filtered for. Monuments exist near spawn at lower rates than in vanilla, pale garden is near spawn far more often than in vanilla.

Threadfinn2 months ago

I think keeping the pale garden goals is fine, but maybe pale garden spawns could be reduced in their filter frequency.

blanket addict2 months ago(edited)

I have no opinion on if they should be in the filter or not (I did like the idea to swap them out for mushroom island near spawn in the filter though)

blanket addict2 months ago

but even if it's removed, I think it's cool to have goals that barely show up involving interesting but otherwise useless things

Jade2 months ago

ok lets not act like mansions are amazing time investments

Jade2 months ago

i do think mansions being more frequent within the pale garden spawns could make them more interesting, a lot of the time they still wouldnt be worth going to so it would functionally stay a structureless seed but its at least a chance to take advantage of a rare structure which to me is a lot more compelling for the seed type than just what the pale garden offers

Jade2 months ago

though for all i know mansion already is a separate seed type in the misc category, idk where that info is visible

blanket addict2 months ago

supposedly it is

blanket addict2 months ago

does the misc seed type actually work like this though

Jade2 months ago

yeah maybe pale garden and mansion should just be merged idk

sam2 months ago

Resin goals are fun and have interesting tradeoffs

Threadfinn2 months ago

Oh I didn't realize mushroom is already there

blanket addict2 months ago

I'm not convinced it actually is

Threadfinn2 months ago

I haven't seen it yet

blanket addict2 months ago(edited)

if it is working as intended I feel like it should like swap rarity with pale garden

blanket addict2 months ago(edited)

or like whatever's being done to filter for it is too broad and it doesn't show up in games as much as it should

mr. pineappleOP2 months ago

These games are not fun, it turns into slop when you need to run just to find a village or smth which is required for several goals