Too many ideas i had

Open

PacBot31 messagesstarted May 28, 2026, 9:50 PM

gameplayobjectives

PacBotOP4 days ago(edited)

die to 5 unique mobs
die with 8+ levels
die to entity cram

Obtain grass block
Obtain 3 different bed colors
Obtain 3 different types of eggs (normal egg blue egg brown egg sniffer egg dragon egg turtle egg)

Obtain "Subspace Bubble" advancemet
Obtain "Stay Hydrated!" advancemet
Obtain "Postmortal" advancemet
Obtain 3-7 advancemets in a specific category
-The End 3
-Nether 5
-Minecraft 7
-Husbandry 7
-Adventure 7

Wear full armor, all different material
wear a mob head

kill 5 unique baby mobs
kill a blaze with a snow ball

use a cartography table
use a blaze rod as fuel

stay at half a heart for a minute

ride 3 unique mobs

50/50 (at the start of the match one player gets this at random)

glow ink sac on crimson/warped sign -> glow ink sac on any random sign/hanging sign
Obtain redstone lamp -> light a redstone lamp
Obtain soul lantern -> obtain all lanterns
Obtain dispenser -> shoot an arrow with a dispenser

change icon of mine crafter to have a pickaxe
change icon of kill unique hostile mobs to have mobs
change icon of jukebox to have a disc

edit: wear carved pumpkin for 5m -> 3m

121

Elag4224 days ago

subspace bubble and postmortal seem meh, kind of annoying but ig
obtain advs in a category maybe seems alright but depends on the tab and stuff
mob head bad unless ancient city or smth, ig gamble wither skeletons though so maybe
half heart for a minute holy bacap reference
50/50 just sucks
changing icon of kill unique hostile mobs is good but the other icon changes not so much
and the rest seem fine

Torca4 days ago

I like most of these, 50/50 is horrible though, and I don’t really agree with the ones where you change the goals that already exist. Also I think blaze rods have enough uses that the fuel one isn’t that interesting. The rest are cool so I’ll upvote

Elag4224 days ago

oh yeah there’s like a ton of goals requiring blaze rods

blanket addict4 days ago(edited)

(really neat timesink goal highlighting cool mechanic)

(cool versatile early game goal imo)

(unsure on subspace bubble I've thought about it too, it might make for a really good endgame goal and it also overlaps with end goals, but it might just be too commital and long)

(I like the idea a lot but only if doing a bastion almost always gets you a dried ghast or if finding them naturally is easy)

(no idea how the advancement category goals would play in practice, the end goal one I dislike but the rest might be good but I can't judge)

(very versatile goal that feels like it should exist)

(seems fun how it kinda mixes exploration with breeding)

(really good goal that's easy with a shipwreck but versatile without one)

(really cool super early game goal having to route getting to half a heart first)

(fun tweak)

(good UI)

(that might be better but I think it's fine as is too)

(good UI)

blanket addict4 days ago

ok this is probably harder to match up than I thought it would be while typing sorry

blanket addict4 days ago

the ones I don't like are mostly because either I think the goal is too hard and/or too RNG in practice to be a good addition (postmortal, mob head, 3 eggs, grass block) or kinda redundant without adding a ton (die to 5 unique mobs is ok but kinda tedious, die with 8+ levels very similar to get 10 levels, kill blaze with snowball very similar to kill snow golem in nether, use blaze rod as fuel is basically kill blaze and there's cooler fortress goals)

blanket addict4 days ago(edited)

and then a couple others I disagree with, I like glow ink being a nether goal it adds more depth than just finding glow squid first, all lanterns largely comes down to finding a monument and it should be its own goal if anything, 50/50 does not sound fun

PacBotOP4 days ago

i should have been more specific i meant normal lantern soul lantern and copper lantern not sea lantern

blanket addict4 days ago

oh yeah 3/4 lanterns would be very similar (if jack o lantern counts I kinda like the idea of 3 lanterns because then there's a few ways to do it)

ilikecheese2164 days ago

make 50/50 a 51/49 for the funnies

awesomeSallad4 days ago

I’m stealing @blanket addict’s format bc it’s good

I like the concept but if feels too tedious. I feel like 3 mobs could be better? Also a goal to die in any five unique ways would be cool

idk just feels weird

rng

i like the different ways to do this + potential overlap/decision making

seems too grindy with low overlap potential

these just seem weird to me idk

this seems to basically just be either skeleton killing which sounds very tedious

boring

oh hell no

I like how the current goal is because you have to do cave and nether

legit just get a single plank

I like this as what @blanket addict said, get three out of the five (including jack-o’-lantern and sea lantern)

basically no change. I could see a “kill mob with dispenser” goal that could use arrows as well as other sources of damage from dispensers being good

these last three are all just flat out good changes

Elag4224 days ago

good format lemme do it

Elag4224 days ago

Stats>Odds4 days ago

a little tedious

very tedious

maybe like 3

good idea put make it a separate objective

also a separate objective for each individual

maybe add a pickaxe?

add a disc?

Cobbet4 days ago

Love grass block, kill baby mobs, kill blaze with snowball + rod as fuel, different armour, cartography table, half heart, ride 3 mobs, the lamp/dispenser I can see working

Tacomonster3 days ago

i suggested half heart for a minute in #BAC goals and entity cram in #Death Goalslol

Tacomonster3 days ago(edited)

ride unique mobs, baby kills, cartography table, stay hydrated, and full armor are pretty good too, the rest are mid/bad

maskers3 days ago

i like obtain grass block (kill an enderman that picked up one), obtain 3 eggs (fits well with existing goals), kill blaze with snowball (also feel like would fit well)

Elag4223 days ago

grass block is funny because if you get unlucky then you can try boating an enderman through a nether portal

awesomeSallad3 days ago

im not a fan of grass block because it seems pretty rng. i guess you could get it in a boat but

blanket addict3 days ago

I agree with that having to get an enderman in the overworld and then bring it to an area with lots of grass just sounds super RNG

blanket addict3 days ago

and the more guaranteed enderman in warped tped to overworld strat is cool but you have to blind around grass and it's so late game I think it's very likely to lose it to RNG by then

blanket addict3 days ago(edited)

I wish there was some kind of silk touch goal though where silk touch makes it easy if you luck into it and otherwise it's reliably late game, but an overworld enderman goal is not reliably late game

Threadfinn3 days ago

I feel like obtain grass block is perfect for this. You can luck into either an enderman holding it or silk touch in a ruined portal. If you don't get lucky then silk touch is reliable to get late game.

blanket addict3 days ago

I feel like silk touch from etable is really out of the way so it'd come down to enderman RNG a lot

Threadfinn3 days ago

You could also trade with villagers for a book. It definitely is time consuming without getting lucky but there's already a good number of goals that are really luck based and this one at least has a guaranteed fallback.

blanket addict3 days ago(edited)

actually I might have been overestimating how hard it is to get silk touch from an enchanting table

blanket addict3 days ago

I think if you can reliably get silk touch as the shown enchant requiring between 15-20 levels when enchanting gold tools, then it's probably fine

blanket addict3 days ago

depends how many rerolls you need on average for it to show up, if it's over like 5 then that's pretty ugly but if it's not it seems pretty chill

blanket addict3 days ago

I think librarian is probably not viable because you need emeralds, grinding resetting it, and an anvil