Kill unique hostile mobs

Open

Elag42224 messagesstarted May 28, 2026, 7:45 PM

gameplay

Elag422OP4 days ago

Neutral (not hostile) mobs like spider, enderman, and piglin are counted towards this. probably not a bug but it’s bad description

maskers4 days ago

https://discord.com/channels/1493030345048719483/1507261479240597524/1507332937450782740 i agree with r0hkx that it shouldn't be based on the wiki

maskers4 days ago

idrk how would it be more clear though

Carrot4 days ago(edited)

Its this list right? So technically "Monster". But if I saw "Kill x unique monsters" i'd probably be a lot more confused than what it is right now.
Only one that im not sure if it does count is zombie horse? (and sulfur cube for future updates - cos that definitly shouldnt be considered hostile)

maskers4 days ago

https://discord.com/channels/1493030345048719483/1495250062970847343/1509498405007655002 its currently every mob that inherits from the Enemy class* (which is different from the mob cap the mob is in, ocelots don't count)
* and zombie/skeleton horses but only if they have a rider? i don't get why its like this

maskers4 days ago

zombie nautilus, camel husk don't count

maskers4 days ago

pretty sure

Carrot4 days ago

ahh thats weird

marin4 days ago(edited)

these will be added, its an oversight

marin4 days ago

in closed beta people mentioned that zombie horse (with a rider) should count

maskers4 days ago(edited)

its weird to me that killing the zombie horse first counts but killing the rider first doesn't count

marin4 days ago

it is weird

marin4 days ago

wiki says

A zombie horse is an undead variant of the horse. It rarely spawns in dark areas as a hostile mob being ridden and controlled by a zombie horseman wielding an iron spear. It becomes passive once separated from the zombie rider.

maskers4 days ago(edited)

"passive" just means ai though, wouldnt it be the same as oneshotting a spider at day time
or a piglin while wearing gold armor

marin4 days ago

hm spider is classified as neutral

marin4 days ago

but this says those 3 are monsters

marin4 days ago

it's mostly just semantics, if most people agree they should be hostiles, they will be added to the goal

Uniquepotatoes4 days ago

monsters is probably a clearer description than hostile mobs tbh

Uniquepotatoes4 days ago

but yeah either the horses should always count or never count

inoutoftherain4 days ago

zombie horse is required for monsters hunted in all advancements and that doesn't care if it's being ridden or not at the time

Elag422OP4 days ago

true just make it all the mobs in monsters hunted and say unique monsters

Elag422OP4 days ago

wait why does the monsters hunted description say hostile mobs why is mc also wrong

Elag422OP4 days ago

well just because mc got it wrong doesn’t mean draftout should do the same

r0hkx4 days ago

monster hunter/monsters hunted criteria is probably the best thing to use here. its what vanilla considers to be a "monster" and the wording of the goals should be changed to "monster" to make that more clear. according to the wiki its these 41 mobs:
- Blaze
- Bogged
- Breeze
- Camel Husk
- Cave Spider
- Creaking (by destroying its creaking heart)
- Creeper
- Drowned
- Elder Guardian
- Ender Dragon
- Enderman
- Endermite
- Evoker
- Ghast
- Guardian
- Hoglin
- Husk
- Magma Cube
- Parched
- Phantom
- Piglin
- Piglin Brute
- Pillager
- Ravager
- Shulker
- Silverfish
- Skeleton
- Slime
- Spider
- Stray
- Vex
- Vindicator
- Witch
- Wither
- Wither Skeleton
- Zoglin
- Zombie
- Zombie Horse
- Zombie Nautilus
- Zombie Villager
- Zombified Piglin
https://minecraft.wiki/w/Advancement#List_of_advancements