Discord Forum Board

Feinberg2 weeks ago(edited)

first one is good
second one seems very tedious
theres already a use grindstone goal, i could see this being repetitive
fourth is good
fifth i like the most
sixth is kinda slop but its good
seventh is good
eighth is good

15

Nojusjo/champ2 weeks ago

I'm not sure if any of these are already in game but:

1.Smelt X amount of Unique items
1.1 Craft X amount of Unique items
2. Deal (100/200/300) Damage to entities
3.Clean a shulker box ( hard goal)
4. Clean Leather Armor
4.1 Clean Banner
5. Ride an entity
5.1 Ride a/an happy ghast/horse/nautilus/pig/strider (maybe for a certain distance too?)

Peti2 weeks ago

I think 1.1, 2, 4 is already in it
Smelling is kinda boring
5 ride entity with saddle otherwise it would be just rightclicking horse race

Ciel2 weeks ago

1.1 is not in it, currently there is "Craft more unique items than your opponent", not a specific amount

Peti2 weeks ago

my bad

Ciel2 weeks ago

Also, I don't think smelting x unique items is boring, it could lead to nice multitask

Ciel2 weeks ago

but it needs to be small, like 5

nsla2 weeks ago

5.1, 4, 2 are all already in and 1.1 has a different functionality in-game of having more crafts than your opponent

Peti2 weeks ago

My ideas (dont know if they aree in it but havent seen them)
- Start a raid
- Cure zombie villager
- get wither skull
- use totem of undying
- get to exact level (10,20,30...)
- Collect every wood type
- Use every or like X ammount throwable item s(snowball, egg, eye of ender, ender pearl, splash potion, wind charge, bottle o´encahnting)
- Tame dog / cat
- Full inventory of unique items (36 unique items at same time)
- Eat X ammount of unique food

Peti2 weeks ago

I though it would be as the crafting one which is the most unique

Ciel2 weeks ago(edited)

5, 9, 10 are already in, and we already have Tame dog and Tame cat, don't know if putting both in one goal is interesting. Collect every wood type is hell on earth

1

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago

For the second one you can just craft 37 wooden shovels, idk how that’s tedious (Also was not expecting you to reply here holy, love your draftout vods!)

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

My ideas:
- Wear 4 Unique Armor Pieces (different material for each)
- Kill Bogged
- Enter End Gateway
- Lock a Map using Cartography Table
- Fill a Shelf with Shelves
- Obtain 64 Coarse Dirt
- Obtain every type of Furnace
- Obtain every type of Torch
- Obtain Beehive
- Obtain Colored Harness (specific color)
- Obtain Gilded Blackstone
- Obtain Nautilus Armor
- Obtain Smooth Quartz Stairs
- Obtain Tinted Glass
- Obtain "Mob Kabob" Advancement
- Have Effects Applied for 5/8/10 Minutes
- Construct Copper Golem
- Create a Waypoint by using a Map on a Banner
- Place a Painting
- Take Damage from 8/12/15 Unique Sources (unique damage types: suffocation, fall, mob_attack, etc.)

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

I was thinking wash banner, requires dye loom cauldron and the banner, a bit more difficult than wash leather armor

baipandaa2 weeks ago

1. 27 beds

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago

This isn’t much different from stack of X colored wool

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago

Never knew you could do that

Ciel2 weeks ago

some of these are way too random, Obtain Smooth Quartz Stairs, Obtain Tinted Glass?

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago

Not really

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago

There’s strategy around getting these goals

baipandaa2 weeks ago

If you've played yet another bingo those are very similar goals to that mod

nsla2 weeks ago

the last 3 are already in

baipandaa2 weeks ago

I think the non stackable makes it slightly diff than a stack of wool

Ciel2 weeks ago

not different enough

Ciel2 weeks ago

also, collect beehive needs silk touch right? or am I mistaken

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

beehive is the craftable one

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

and honeycomb found in trial chambers

Ciel2 weeks ago

ah, I see

Peti2 weeks ago

Crafting items bingo event

would prob be a bit boring

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago

Get 81 wood and wool, drop your items, and craft them all

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago

Really not too different

Tacomonster2 weeks ago(edited)

Stealing from Bacap:
compost 10/25/40 unique items
ignite 10/20/30 unique flammable blocks
plant 5/10/15 unique things in flower pot
die to 5/8/12 unique mobs
break 3/5/10 unique items (tool + armor)

baipandaa2 weeks ago

Is eating unique items already in game?

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago

Yes, 4 times

Ciel2 weeks ago

eating unique foods yes

1

Ciel2 weeks ago

Goal "Rename a grass block 'Minecraft' "

22

Ciel2 weeks ago

I don't think there's a rename goal already

Ciel2 weeks ago

this is a good one

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

grass block is tough

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago

Maybe a lil hard cuz you need silk touch, but you can also get an enderman to pick 1 up

Ciel2 weeks ago

ah maybe

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

yeah

Prez2 weeks ago

4 pieces of uniquely dyed leather armour

2

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

although I prefer silk end goal over end stuff (cause I can’t speedrun)

Ciel2 weeks ago

already in

Peti2 weeks ago

Maybe use a nametag on a mob slightly easier than a grass block, but that´s just getting an anvil

Prez2 weeks ago

wow whoever came up with that is a genius

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

yeah could just make it nyan sheep from bacap

Prez2 weeks ago

is there a list of goals or are you going off of vods and stuff

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

already in the mod

Ciel2 weeks ago

going off vods

Prez2 weeks ago

clogs

Peti2 weeks ago

I moer liked the 4 unique amror pieces that each has to be dioffrent material

1

Prez2 weeks ago

every big leather goal in bingo is annoying

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

wait dive bomb from bacap is also good

1

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

(jump in water from 50+ blocks)

Peti2 weeks ago

MLG clutch with watrer bucket from 50+ blocks

1

Ciel2 weeks ago

if you have a bad pc you're just fucked

Peti2 weeks ago

if you play on like 20 fps u fucked either way

Ciel2 weeks ago

that's not a good mindset

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

well this would be another way of doing the same thing

1

Peti2 weeks ago

but i get the point

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

it’s better to keep it as dive bomb and if you’re good at the game just land the mlg

2

Peti2 weeks ago

yeah but bit harder

Ciel2 weeks ago

rewards being good

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

how would you detect it

Ciel2 weeks ago(edited)

I'm sure it's feasible, and that's not our job to think about that

Peti2 weeks ago

Same as you but would believe you can detect placing water bucket

baipandaa2 weeks ago

craft unique fireworks?

Prez2 weeks ago

or like a firework with x amount of different explosions

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

idk it seems like you could cheese it by placing a water bucket against a wall or smt instead of landing the clutch

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

hmm

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

you could probably make it like

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

obtain firework with these patterns

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

and it picks the dye and trail etc

Ciel2 weeks ago

ah you mean MLG? we are not putting the goal MLG, that's not happening. It's dive bomb and MLG is a faster way to do it, but if it's just dive bomb you can detect it

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

I was just explaining why detecting mlg might be difficult, I think it’s best to keep it as dive bomb

Ciel2 weeks ago

I see

Peti2 weeks ago

yeah thats fair

Prez2 weeks ago

could you not check if player velocity in 0 and then if theyre in water?

Ciel2 weeks ago

we were talking about detecting MLG, not dive bomb

Prez2 weeks ago

yeah

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago(edited)

get 3/5/10 unique enchantments (total number on items in inventory)

Feinberg2 weeks ago

ohhh im stupid its good then

junesies 🌸2 weeks ago

1 billion shovels

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

fill a bundle with bundles

Ciel2 weeks ago

Do you think the goal "Rename a grass block as 'Minecraft' " is too difficult? you need silk touch

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

i mean silk touch isnt impossible

Ciel2 weeks ago

maybe too long

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

theres end stuff tho

Feinberg2 weeks ago

its fine as a lategame goal

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago

A back and forth goal of “have the most wooden shovels in your inventory”

2

nsla2 weeks ago

too rng me thinks i dont want to struggle finding silk touch the whole run

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

its pefect cos it would be the #1 chat interaction bait asking what it is

junesies 🌸2 weeks ago

this would be horrendous

junesies 🌸2 weeks ago

i kind of love it

Ciel2 weeks ago

same

baipandaa2 weeks ago

Is rabbit stew in the game already, that would be a fun stretch

1

junesies 🌸2 weeks ago

villagers wouldn’t be too bad for that though right?

junesies 🌸2 weeks ago

ya it is

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

is there something like shoot a mob with a tipped arrow

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago

People often get it from villager trading

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

or shoot a firework out of a crossbow

1

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago(edited)

Yes, that exists

Prez2 weeks ago

hit yourself with an invisibility arrow

1

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

get the glowing effect could be fun

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

cos it doesnt require tedious potion crafts

Ciel2 weeks ago

ugh

baipandaa2 weeks ago

Or spectral

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

in the mod

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

oh lmao

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago

Often you have to hit yourself with a spectral arrow for get 3/4/5/6 effects at once

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

will the website have a list of all squares when it launches

Ciel2 weeks ago

would be good lmao

nsla2 weeks ago

technically no but it can either be insta or take multiple minutes and its just bad to have goals like that imo

nsla2 weeks ago

and then on top of that u need an anvil

nsla2 weeks ago

just overcooked

Ciel2 weeks ago

Drink 10 water bottles

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

this should have all the goals that were in beta
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/12D5VGkG4Rzegl4S6_9VjoXA4ksbSztwtKIFrmxDfH2o/edit?usp=sharing

4

Ciel2 weeks ago

would be good if that spreadsheet was more easily visible

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

if the website had like a secion with all goals and the info in this sheet it would be so peak

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

literally made it a few days ago myself lol

Ciel2 weeks ago

yeah but it's nice, we need some table to see every goal

junesies 🌸2 weeks ago

ok ya that would be rly boring

junesies 🌸2 weeks ago

fire pfp btw

1

Peti2 weeks ago

its luck based

Peti2 weeks ago

ruined portal / bastion loot

junesies 🌸2 weeks ago

u could just highroll it in an rp yeah

Nojusjo/champ2 weeks ago

luck is seeded, but it would lowk just be an annoying task overtime

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

theres so much luck in this anyway

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

like any of the kill unique hostile mobs is just pure luck

Peti2 weeks ago(edited)

ye but i mean like you can search it for a long time

Ciel2 weeks ago

? it's not that much luck

nsla2 weeks ago

so what if one person went one direction and didnt find a structure with silk touch but an opponent went a different way and insta found jt

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

i mean like at night what if one player gets a witch/zillager spawn etc

Peti2 weeks ago

Enderman can pick it up

nsla2 weeks ago

ur dying on this hill too hard wdym we’re now falling back to enderman picking up blocks

nsla2 weeks ago

like do u hear urself

Ciel2 weeks ago

it's not that strong, you can always play biomes and nether, one more mob doesn't help that much

Peti2 weeks ago

im saying theoreticly u dont need silk touch

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

theres already bound to be a bunch of luck in lockouts

Peti2 weeks ago

but still feels too much random

Peti2 weeks ago

what if nobody find it for like hour?

nsla2 weeks ago

then the game is boring until someone gets lucky or forces a village

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

kill witch and kill zombie villager exist

junesies 🌸2 weeks ago

you still need an anvil and that seems like it could be rly boring

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

which are just pure luck squares unless u force it with a swamp or village

nsla2 weeks ago(edited)

like if a goal isnt gotten in over an hour and it isn’t a progression goal (end city, dragon egg) it’s just an overcomplicated shitty goal

6

junesies 🌸2 weeks ago

yeah

Ciel2 weeks ago

on these, fair

nsla2 weeks ago

witch hut ow type….

junesies 🌸2 weeks ago

need that

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

you can also just start raid and get witches there

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

tbh a solution to having more complex squares would just have a set of advanced squares introduced at higher elo

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago(edited)

where people can do harder things in a reasonable time

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

pretty sure rowl said in the vid that something similar would be implemented

Ciel2 weeks ago

I mean he said they were gonna be ways for beginners to learn in a beginner mode, nut that some things would be exclusive to higher elo

Ciel2 weeks ago

I personally don't like the idea of having some players play a different game than others, BT in MCSR ranked is fine cause it's seed based, you're still playing the same game if not BT

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

yea thats why i said something similar nod

Mango [TGO]2 weeks ago

i think this would probably be a separate suggestion thread some time

Ciel2 weeks ago

What about "Break all end crystals"?

Ciel2 weeks ago

Rewards good aiming

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

thoughts on these?

Nojusjo/champ2 weeks ago

a lot of those feel time wasteful instead of something u have to be strategic with

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

wdym time wasteful

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

maybe flammable blocks cause it’s just crafting all the wood stuff, but I do still think that’s a bit unique

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

but like compost is 100% strategy, you need to find which things would be easiest

Nojusjo/champ2 weeks ago

die to mobs is just death reset during night time like 20 times breaking tools is just hoe + gold armor spam

Nojusjo/champ2 weeks ago

u will lose multiple goals if u go for one of those

blanket addict2 weeks ago(edited)

my goal idea is that many of the goals should randomize traits more but not take up extra goal slots (an example that currently exists would be the stack of x colour wool goal, I think a lot of goals that currently exist or could exist could take this approach too)

blanket addict2 weeks ago(edited)

an obvious thing that could be randomized is number of things for certain goals (stuff like 7/10 hostiles, spy on x mobs, eat x foods, leash x mobs, get x status effects at once, get 7 workstations), some of those are definitely better with set numbers (status effects, hostiles, foods are probably better as set numbers) but I like the idea of some of them instead being 1 goal that just picks a random number from a range of numbers (like leash 2-8 unique mobs, spy on 5-20 unique mobs, get 7-12 workstations)

blanket addict2 weeks ago(edited)

I just think it'd be cool if more goals pulled from ranges of outcomes in ways that resulted in them spiritually being the same idea, but playing differently from game to game (like how stack of lime wool is very different from stack of yellow wool, or how leashing 4 unique mobs is way easier than 8, or how kill 7 hostiles is just a nether goal but 10 hostiles is a nether and then kill some weird mobs goal, I want there to be many goals that through randomizating a factor create emergent variation in play patterns)

Tacomonster2 weeks ago(edited)

unique mobs and unique tools/armor, you can’t just die to the same ones or break the same few

Nojusjo/champ2 weeks ago

each piece of gold armor is unique so thats 4 each gold tool is like 6

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

gold armor is slower to break than wooden tools and stuff

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

plus getting all the gold might be slower than just wood and leather

Nojusjo/champ2 weeks ago

u prob wanna prefer doing combos of goals that overlap eachother before singular ones that take like 3 min on their own

Tacomonster2 weeks ago(edited)

yeah, this is a goal thats harder to overlap

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

doesn’t make it bad

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

I mean you can probably break a pickaxe mining for raw blocks or some armor when exploring nether

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

there’s strategy to it

blanket addict2 weeks ago(edited)

doesn't this just mean something is a later game goal

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

mhm

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

if you go for it early and lose goals, it’s a problem with your routing not the goal itself

blanket addict2 weeks ago

I like the composter idea, I don't really like the flammable blocks idea, flower pot one I'm unsure on, die to mobs could either be really cool or really awful, breaking unique items I think I'd prefer a different version of instead of it being number based

blanket addict2 weeks ago

die to mobs I think depends on how interesting it is to actually set up death resets for that many different mobs

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

hmm true

blanket addict2 weeks ago

I think it'd be pretty boring now that I think about it a bit more it'd probably be more fun to just have a couple "die to x mob" goals that are fun

blanket addict2 weeks ago

like maybe die to ghast would be neat (but ghast RNG maybe annoying)

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

flammable blocks is a bit weird cause it’s ruined by wood crafts, but at lower values it might still be faster to burn foliage? not sure

blanket addict2 weeks ago

flammable blocks I just don't like because it feels weird as a goal

blanket addict2 weeks ago(edited)

it just feels like it'd never be a statistic in the game (if minecraft tracks this as a stat then that's weird as hell make it a goal) it feels too disconnected from the player to me

Tacomonster2 weeks ago(edited)

breaking items might be more interesting if it specified a few which included like fishing rod or shears

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

grinding shovel and hoe breaks isn’t fun

blanket addict2 weeks ago

yeah I agree with that

blanket addict2 weeks ago

I kinda want a goal like break an iron pickaxe

blanket addict2 weeks ago

something that's not easy to do extremely quickly but also not insanely tedious

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

bac detects it somehow

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

it’s just like flint and steel used on block?

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

it’s kinda weird I can see that

blanket addict2 weeks ago(edited)

my reasoning is basically like how something like "place blocks in the shape of a creeper face" or something should never be a goal imo, it feels like the same kind of thing to me, but if there's a real stat for it that doesn't have to be modded in that's like a weird novel thing and I like when bingo highlights weird novel things

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

it’s not really building a structure

blanket addict2 weeks ago

it's just a vibes thing where it feels like it happens in the world to me rather than it being a direct extension of the player

Tacomonster2 weeks ago(edited)

I view it more like an item use than build

blanket addict2 weeks ago

it's just a vibes thing I might be the odd one out here

blanket addict2 weeks ago

as a goal I do like the idea of something that incentivizes just crafting a ton of different wooden items

blanket addict2 weeks ago

craft more unique items only kinda does this

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

a fun early game goal could be suffocating to death

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

but there’s some cool strats which allow you suffocate in more places than just a beach

tacopizza2 weeks ago

Is there smth like get a certain amount of advancements or maybe certain amount of advancements from a certain category?

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

status tab is named advancements btw

blanket addict2 weeks ago

there's obtain 20 advancements but I think that's it

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

ty

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

im actively working on it rn peepoGiggle

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

do you guys think mob transport goals would be fun

Tacomonster2 weeks ago(edited)

probably something easy like kill chicken in the nether

tacopizza2 weeks ago

I like it

tacopizza2 weeks ago

Kill an overworld mob in the nether or vice versa

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

chicken I think is the best cause you can do it with eggs or…

zombfied piglin jockey!

tacopizza2 weeks ago

Yh

tacopizza2 weeks ago

But tbf with a boat any mob is quite easy

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

yeah

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

you’d probably want a lead so transporting is faster

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

could be done early game with just boat if it’s nearby tho

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

there’s variance

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

also chickens you can lure with seeds

tacopizza2 weeks ago

True and those recipes got way easier

tacopizza2 weeks ago

It would be cool to have a specific passive mob and could be any

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

what nether mob would be good in the overworld

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

definitely not uneasy alliance

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

probably just zombified piglin

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

can’t wait for the game where it thunders and you have channeling tridents before nether access so striking a pig is useful

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

there’s also structure transport like idk kill sheep in a shipwreck

tacopizza2 weeks ago

Yh that

tacopizza2 weeks ago

But with lead any mob is possible really

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

except the ones that can’t be leaded

tacopizza2 weeks ago

True

tacopizza2 weeks ago

So I would exceed those then

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

guys I know how to fix the kill bat goal. make it kill bat in the nether!!!

tacopizza2 weeks ago

POV pain

baipandaa2 weeks ago

what's the niche tech

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

it’s on my yt :)

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

mainly just like using boats and rideable mobs

blanket addict2 weeks ago(edited)

nvm there's goals for obtain 10/20/30 advancements

blanket addict2 weeks ago

I was just wrong

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

I was playing this datapack where you tried to die as fast as possible from a random spawn so I developed quick ways to die to suffocation

blanket addict2 weeks ago

if you have to kill 10 bats it should standardize the RNG a lot

blanket addict2 weeks ago

or 20

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

what about kill bat in an end city

Coinly2 weeks ago(edited)

i really liked the item frame goal so maybe
1. Push a piston with a piston
2. Grab a hopper with a hopper
3. Observe an observer with an observer
any of those seem fun and quick, especially the piston one. Sorry if these exist already

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

is that easier

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

wdym with the third one

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

daylight detector can’t detect daylight detectors right

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

like maybe if they’re stacked?

Prez2 weeks ago

crafters crafting crafters advancement is cool

Coinly2 weeks ago

observer I mean whoops

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

ah lol

maskers2 weeks ago

get a world record (rename a music disc to "world")

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

what about squished to death

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

that would be a fun goal

Peti2 weeks ago(edited)

Is there a goal for respawning using the respawn anchor?

ilikecheese216OP2 weeks ago

There’s a goal to die by it (or bed)

Peti2 weeks ago

I know that but like respawning in nether

Peti2 weeks ago

Also I thought about goal for getting above the nether roof but feels annoying and kinda risky if someone forget to stash their items

maskers2 weeks ago(edited)

- Obtain a Weakness Arrow
- Get Slowness
- Get Regeneration
- Bounce up 10 (?) blocks from a Slime Block
- Obtain Bamboo Pressure Plate
- Obtain Copper Bulb
- Obtain Waxed Exposed Cut Copper Stairs
- Eat Enchanted Golden Apple
- Get a baby chicken from an Egg

maskers2 weeks ago

i think it already exists

2

Peti2 weeks ago

love the chicken one

maskers2 weeks ago

half of these are "easy if you find the right biome but you can try to force them in a trial chamber" which i feel like is a good goal type

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

Egap is annoying unless there’s a way to detect loot prior to generating it

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

Cuz ik loot doesn’t get generated on world spawn, it gets generated on a player opening it

maskers2 weeks ago

maybe, i was thinking you get a decent amount of them from trial chambers & ancient cities in bac but idk just how annoying itd be with basic gear

maskers2 weeks ago

you don't need silk touch, the tech is to kill an enderman

blanket addict2 weeks ago(edited)

some random early game ideas:
obtain 64 crafting tables
kill 10 mobs
mine gold block
grow up an animal (is this possible to actually check for? activates by a baby that you gave food to becoming an adult)

blanket addict2 weeks ago(edited)

I think early game filler goals are extremely important and there should be as many as possible

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

suffocate to death

blanket addict2 weeks ago

I support suffocate to death

blanket addict2 weeks ago(edited)

it's just get boat and time sink or get sand/gravel and time sink right

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

4effects is already a goal

blanket addict2 weeks ago(edited)

oops edited it out

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

i also like squished to death as a late game goal

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

theres tech to do it more midgame tho

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

my fav tech for 4 effects is just find an egap in RP chest first minute of the game

blanket addict2 weeks ago

honestly I think 8 effects should be a goal too

blanket addict2 weeks ago

I think 8 is exactly enough that you usually don't do potions

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

if you get trial chamber effects/potions 8 can be doable

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

But it’s a significant jump from 6 imo

blanket addict2 weeks ago

is there an easy 8th effect actually besides pufferfish gap wither and glowing

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

any sus stew

blanket addict2 weeks ago(edited)

and I guess including wither might kill you too quickly

Ethan :32 weeks ago(edited)

for when 26.2 releases:
- Obtain 3/5/7 "chiseled" stone blocks (of Cinnabar, Sulfur, Deepslate, Stone, Sandstone, Tuff, Nether Brick, Blackstone, etc.)
- Advancement "Uh Oh" (tnt in a sulfur cube)
- Die by magma block in a sulfur cube (new damage type "minecraft:sulfur_cube_hot")

maskers2 weeks ago(edited)

- Die to Zombie riding a Zombie Horse
eh yeah this one does seem too rng

blanket addict2 weeks ago

is there a way for that one to not be RNG

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

Reminder to add bucket of sulfur cube to 6 unique buckets code :p

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

For when 26.2 releases ^

blanket addict2 weeks ago(edited)

is there a number that'd make obtain x emeralds a not stupid goal

Ethan :32 weeks ago

there's what - empty, water, lava, salmon, cod, pufferfish, tropical fish, axolotl, and sulfur cube?

blanket addict2 weeks ago

64 seems stupid and if you can just easily trade wheat it's stupid but if it's just "make a fletcher" that seems boring too

Ethan :32 weeks ago

did i miss any?

Astro2 weeks ago

idk if this is one already but complete a raid

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

powder snow

1

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

think there’s kill all raid mobs

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

unless they took it out

Ethan :32 weeks ago

omg milk too

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

^

Ethan :32 weeks ago

and tadpole

Ethan :32 weeks ago

i googled it

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

I forgot about tadpole

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

It’s just never one you go for though

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

Cuz you not only need slime+frogs but then u wait like 10 minutes for them to hatch

maskers2 weeks ago

- Obtain 32 Bricks (blocks)
- Obtain Careful Restoration Advancement (Make a Decorated Pot out of 4 Pottery Sherds)
- Mine Podzol
- Swap 9 hotbar slots using Shelves
- Obtain Mob Head
- Obtain Nautilus Armor

Tacomonster2 weeks ago(edited)

wondering if we should make a separate thread where people post lists of goals without people commenting on them (maybe just reactions of

or

)

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

its gonna be difficult to see the suggestions with the discussion

tacopizza2 weeks ago

I was debating making a spreadsheet for this

tacopizza2 weeks ago

Could do so tmr

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

I could make an extra sheet page on the goal list sheet I already made

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

If people would find that helpful

tacopizza2 weeks ago

Sure

r0hkx2 weeks ago

yeah i was gonna say, ideally a new thread should be made for each objective or family of objectives

r0hkx2 weeks ago

this thread is incomprehensible in terms of an actual suggestion

1

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

yeah its more of a discussion on certain suggestions

Tacomonster2 weeks ago(edited)

which is totally fair but it just makes it hard to see the suggestions lol

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

ideally it would have a slowmode but that requires a moderator...

r0hkx2 weeks ago

i mean this thread is fine as a meta discussion thread, but the individual suggestions will be lost

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

yeah i was saying you could make a new thread and give it slowmode for people to post their actual suggestions

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

then you could link or forward them here and discuss

r0hkx2 weeks ago

it should just be one thread -> one suggestion + discussion about that suggestion

r0hkx2 weeks ago

slowmode might be a good idea though anywaysp

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

mk

awesomeSallad2 weeks ago

I really like 4 here

Ethan :32 weeks ago

where did you make this? is there a link?

isqqcle2 weeks ago

we can also pin messages in a thread but its still gross

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

yeah the link was sent already if you scroll up

Tacomonster2 weeks ago(edited)

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/12D5VGkG4Rzegl4S6_9VjoXA4ksbSztwtKIFrmxDfH2o (made by coreybird)

2

Tacomonster2 weeks ago(edited)

there ya go

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

Ty taco

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

And no I haven’t made the ideas page yet

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

If someone makes a thread or something I can scroll through that

RWblox2 weeks ago

idea: die once in every dimension

Semanari2 weeks ago(edited)

Some of these might exist already and I'm just not aware of them but:

Jump the most times
Play the most time in f5
Craft every level of spear (wood-diamond)
Loot X chests (maybe like 5-10)
Trade with villagers X times (maybe like 10)
Buy a specific item from villagers (Like a t2-3 item like iron tools etc.)
Mine each type of ore (coal-diamond)
Aggro zombie piglins
Craft a cake/pumpkin pie
Get to coordinates 0,0,0
Subspace Bubble
Kill/die to a Shulker
Craft a crossbow (this is actually moderately difficult for most people)
Get X different colors of stained glass (or the most, maybe same for hardened clay)
Light TNT with a flint & steel
Travel X blocks in a minecart
Grow a 2x2 tree (jungle/spruce/dark oak)
Have one of each tool in a different level of material (eg. Wood pick, stone shovel, copper axe, iron sword, gold hoe, diamond spear)
Use an Enchanting Table

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

first two are slop
next three are fine
specific item is lowkey just chain armor goal from armorers
all ores might be a bit difficult if you include deepslate variants and ancient debris, otherwise fine
already implimented
eating those is already implimented
0,0,0 could be could with bacap's spawn camping advancement, place a campfire at 0,0,0 would be a bit more strategy based
meh, probably too tedious to be fun
shulker just adds more end goals which i dont think are needed, end rod already exists
firework crossbow is already implimented
glazed terracotta already has a goal
obtain tnt already implimented
ride minecart already implimented, distance might be ok by forcing powered rail
x unique saplings is probably just more strategic
this could be alright but if its added it should replace the spear one from earlier
already implimented

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

shulker requires end city whereas end rod requires outer end but not necessarily city

1

Semanari2 weeks ago

Yeah I think the one tool of each variety is more interesting

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

yeah i think end rod is just better then

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

finding an end city is so rng

Semanari2 weeks ago

I like the idea of forcing people to play in f5 as much as possible because it will force mistakes from the people who aren't used to it

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

its just so bad tho

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

how about survive on half heart for 1 minute Hmm

1

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

if you enable it to begin then people will be tied the entire game

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

just annoying cause its not a goal is more of an inconveince

1

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

trueeee

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

guys just rip more stuff from bacap

Semanari2 weeks ago

Ya I wouldn't include deepslate and debris

Semanari2 weeks ago

Firework crossbow is implemented but that doesn't require u to craft it right

Semanari2 weeks ago

Like

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

why would forcing you to craft it be better

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

i think 90% of the time youre crafting it anyway

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

firework is just more skill based with requiring gunpowder and paper

Semanari2 weeks ago

Actully knowing how to make the tripwire hook and crafting a crossbow is a nonzero skill check

Semanari2 weeks ago

True I figured most ppl just get it bastion

Semanari2 weeks ago

Idk

Semanari2 weeks ago

Modern ver bastion is pawbably completely diff from what I know

Semanari2 weeks ago

Also ya basically all I saw was fein's streams so I had a feeling some of the goals were already real and I just didn't see

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

crossbow recipe is not that obscure

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

ill be honest i just use recipe book

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

i know it requires 2 iron and 2 string

Semanari2 weeks ago

Idk I've never made one

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

its like 3 sticks 1 iron ingot 1 tripwire hook 2 string

Semanari2 weeks ago

I just make bows

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

theres lots of other things like daylight detector that are also craft memorization

Semanari2 weeks ago

First person to press f3 loses is a good goal too

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

i just dont think that would be fun

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

then the optimal strategy is to just never use f3

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

theres no goal that you can quickly come back from by using f3

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

if you use it to find a trial chamber, your opponent can do the same and snipe the goals

Semanari2 weeks ago

It could be use f3 the least recently

Semanari2 weeks ago

You don't insta fail and actually have to weigh re-scanning and using it at a later time

Semanari2 weeks ago

And it might be necessary for things like finding the bastion and trial chamber

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

f3 is skill based, having a goal against it makes the optimal strategy just getting lucky with your exploration

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

nobody wants to lose from opponents getting lucky...

Tacomonster2 weeks ago

it also just doesnt feel like a goal to achieve, its more like a restriction put in place

Coreybirdo2 weeks ago

opponent goals are never good in draftout since theres no way to "force" your opponent to do the thing

ecard2 weeks ago

isnt like do more x than your opponent good tho because you force them to do the thing by doing it yourself or give up the goal

ecard2 weeks ago

like have more levels or something

Semanari2 weeks ago

Yeah it's utilizing your f3 usage more efficiently

Semanari2 weeks ago

Like sure your opp could just never press it but idk

thunderz2 weeks ago(edited)

- Obtain lvl 5 xp (early)
- place 30 unique blocks
- first one to drink any potion bottle
-Eat a cookie
- full diamond armor
- Obtain Unbreaking enchantement/book
- first one to be set on fire (early)
- Obtain a music disc
- make a golem (copper snow iron)
- use a horn
- kill a warden

maskers2 weeks ago

- Obtain Dead Bush
- Obtain Fire Charge

Ciel2 weeks ago(edited)

These two are way too easy to obtain on many seeds, even compared to village goals

maskers2 weeks ago(edited)

i like both of them, idk how common would biomes be but i feel like dead bush is quite rare and for both there are several ways of obtaining (rp loot or biome, trial chamber, fortress/bartering for fire charge)

Ciel2 weeks ago

ah dead bush you're right, but for fire charges imagine there's just an rp in front of you, it's just so random, not satisfying at all

maskers2 weeks ago

this is a thing with a lot of goals though i think? though you can force fire charge a lot easier than, say, cactus if its not in your face which is why i like it

Ciel2 weeks ago

I was thinking about villages and generally villages have multiple goals so there is mindgame about what the other person will choose because there is a time investment, even if it's just collecting bell for example. If you have an rp in front of you though there's pretty much 0 time investment

Ciel2 weeks ago

It's just about who can open the chest faster and that's just lame. And there is no reason not to go for it

r0hkx2 weeks ago

Goal suggestions discussion

r0hkx2 weeks ago

feel free to use this thread to discuss new goal suggestions, but if you want to seriously suggest a new goal/set of goals please make a new thread and move discussion about that specific goal to the new thread

RWblox4 days ago

i think kill breeze with wind charge should be replaced by either kill breeze or obtain wind charge bc it just seems weird atm but i dont mind it

RWblox4 days ago

also when sulphur cubes release it would be fun to see a goal to do with putting a block in one or something

Threadfinn4 days ago

Add all the nametag easter eggs as tasks instead of just having two dinnerbone variations. "Johnny" vindicator, "jeb_" sheep, "Toast" rabbit, and switch one of the current dinnerbone ones to "Grumm".

Semanari4 days ago

You don't need to obtain wind charge for it you can bounce their wind charges back to get the achievement

Semanari4 days ago

I like it it's a fun goal

Semanari4 days ago

Lots of knowing damage thresholds to set it up quicker

Cobbet3 days ago

Random idea, craft fire charge
I don't think anyones ever done that and it's not hard, could be a good nether goal

2

RWblox3 days ago

ohh i didnt know that